Erebus

The Origins of SARS-CoV-2 · source record · paper

Erratum for the Research Article 'The Huanan Seafood Wholesale Market in Wuhan was the early epicenter of the COVID-19 pandemic'

Science · 2024

AI-verified citationSRC-WOROBEY-ERRATUM-2024
identifier / locator
Science 383(6688):eadp1133; DOI 10.1126/science.adp1133; indexed 15 March 2024
url
https://doi.org/10.1126/science.adp1133
verification note
Full erratum text read via a Wayback snapshot dated 2025-04-27; the Crossref update-to record independently confirms it corrects the market epicenter paper and not the lineage paper.
reliability notes
  • A null correction: it fixes duplicated data files and a pseudoreplicate count and states the results were unchanged. Linking it must not imply it weakened the paper's findings.
  • Records a real process-integrity detail: an informal supplementary correction of May 2023 that the journal concedes should have been indexed as a formal erratum, and was not indexed until March 2024.

Evidence drawn from this source

Qualifies· weakCOV-E002

The 2024 erratum: data files corrected, results unchanged

what the source states
The authors identified duplicated data files and a pseudoreplicate count of 10,000 "rather than the n = 1000 used for all related analyses," regenerated the files and re-ran every affected test: "All results remained the same as previously reported: p < 0.001 and p-Adjusted (BH) = 0.003." The notice also records that a correction was posted to the supplementary material on May 8, 2023, and that "Science should have indexed it as a formal Erratum," which occurred on March 15, 2024.
what we infer
Recorded because corrections must be as visible as findings, and because this one is routinely conflated with the separate and substantive correction to the companion lineage paper. This erratum changed no result. Its only substantive content is a ten-month indexing delay, which is a small process-integrity observation about the publication record and not evidence about origins.
limitations
  • Read via a dated archive snapshot because the publisher bot-walls automated clients and the repository deposit carries metadata only.
Science (2024)AI-verified citationCOV-C002